Both publish a free tier, so the usual comparison of price is unavailable. What is left is a harder question: which free tier delivers what the pricing page implies once you try to use it.
Pick Mediamodifier if you need higher resolution, a wider range of models, or an API on the team plan. Test the free tier against your own product first rather than assuming it covers you, because that is precisely the point its reviewers dispute.
Pick Mockey if you want to produce something usable without paying or signing up. The free output is genuinely unwatermarked, and the honest limitation is resolution, which is stated rather than discovered.
Free or paid, both build one image at a time. The tier you pick does not change how many times you assemble the same set.
Mockey's offer is simple and, by the evidence, accurate. The free tier produces images without a watermark, which is unusual in this category, and its reviewers complain about resolution and about the model catalogue rather than about being misled. Resolution is the paid upgrade, and that is stated.
Mediamodifier publishes a free Starter tier listing templates, fonts and image tools, and we rechecked the pricing page. What we cannot verify from outside is whether it delivers, and several reviewers say flatly that it does not. Two put it in almost the same words: that the free plan is a lie and there is no free option.
We are not in a position to settle that, and it would be dishonest to pretend otherwise. What we can say is that one of these two has a free tier nobody argues about, and on a comparison whose entire axis is the free tier, that asymmetry is the finding.
| What you are comparing | Winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Free tier nobody disputes | Mockey | Unwatermarked output at no cost, and its reviewers complain about other things entirely. Mediamodifier's free plan is contested by several of its own. |
| Getting started with no account | Mockey | No signup required to try it, which matters when you are testing whether a design is worth pursuing at all. |
| An API | Mediamodifier | Available on the team plan, and one of the few tools in this bracket to offer one at all. |
| Free output resolution | Mediamodifier | Mockey's clearest limitation and its most common complaint: a reviewer calls the free resolution too poor to be worth using. |
| Model and scene variety | Mediamodifier | A Mockey reviewer flags a real gap: almost no models over 35, which is a problem if that is your customer. |
| Repeating a listing set | Tie | Neither has any concept of it. Both build one image at a time, free or paid. |
Prices shown in USD with automatic local conversion. Excludes tax and VAT.
Paid tier pricing not captured yet.
Our own pricing.
Free, unwatermarked, no signup. Nothing is committed while you are still finding out.
Mockey's free resolution is its weak point and the upgrade path is what you are paying for either way.
A Mockey reviewer describes the model range as almost entirely young, which makes the scenes wrong for that audience.
Free or paid, both assemble each listing image individually. The repetition is untouched by either tier.
A mockup library with a genuinely usable free tier and a mockup API on the team plan, aimed at designers and small brands.
Prices shown in USD with automatic local conversion. Excludes tax and VAT.
Designers who want a solid free library, and teams who need API access to generate mockups from their own system.
A free AI mockup generator with a wide catalogue, aimed at quick one off mockups.
Paid tier pricing not captured yet.
Anyone who needs one quick mockup of a plain design and does not care about matching a house style.
They claim to offer a free started plan but it's a total lie, there is no free option. I would have considered subscribing but I don't buy from dishonest untrustworthy companies.
It's a scam. They will just waste your time. They pretend to have a free plan and are lying to you.
Literally the worst mockup site. It doesn't work properly and lag all the time.
If I can't test how it is going to look in high resolution. I will not use. Your resolution is so poor, it is not worth using
I am sad to see, that Mockey falls in the same trap as many others, by not having a variety of real people as models. No older people 35 or even older. One Granddad Pic does not make up for that. I sell Items to an audience within the range of 35-55+ and i can not advertise with all those fresh and hip young persons.
I would love to pay, but I'm not paying for a whole year when I only need to use the service twice.
What resolution does your marketplace actually require? That decides whether free is enough.
Who are your customers? One of these has a model range skewed young enough for a reviewer to complain.
Have you tried the free tier on your own product, or only read about it?
Is the constraint the tier or the repetition? Only one of those is on this page.
This page is about what a free tier gives you, and neither answer changes the shape of the work. Both tools compose a single image per go, so producing a listing set means doing it once per image and again for the next product, with the title and branding placed by hand each time. That is the part we replace: describe the set once, drop in each new design, get the finished images back. If your volume is low enough that a free tier covers you, it is also low enough that this may not be worth it yet, and that is worth saying.
Yes, with unwatermarked output on the free tier, which is uncommon here. Paid plans exist for higher resolution and more templates, and that limitation is stated rather than hidden.
It publishes a free Starter tier with templates, fonts and image tools. Several reviewers dispute that it delivers, two saying plainly that there is no free option. We cannot settle that from outside, so test it against your own product.
Mediamodifier on resolution and on model variety; Mockey on being genuinely usable for nothing. Judged on output alone at the paid tier they are close, which is why this page compares the free tiers instead.
Mockey for testing, because free and unwatermarked means nothing is committed while you find out whether a design sells. Mediamodifier once resolution matters for a live listing.
No. Both build one image at a time, so ten products cost ten times what one did. Custom Mockup Generator exists for that repetition specifically, and is worth nothing to you if your volume is genuinely low.
Describe your listing set once, then drop in each new design and get the whole set back with your title, size chart and logo already in place.
Browse print generators