Placeit has the larger catalogue by a wide margin. Canva includes mockups at no cost. So the real question is not which library is bigger, it is what the difference is worth every month, and what happens when you decide it is not worth it any more.
Pick Placeit if the catalogue is genuinely your constraint, meaning you have looked for specific scenes in Canva and not found them. Go in knowing that cancellation is the most common complaint against it, and diarise the renewal date before you subscribe.
Pick Canva if mockups are occasional, if budget matters at all, or if you would rather not manage another subscription. It is free, the library is respectable since Smartmockups came across, and stopping costs you nothing.
Neither solves repetition. A bigger library still means composing each listing image by hand, once per product, every time.
Placeit's case is breadth. It has the largest browser mockup catalogue in this comparison, heavy on lifestyle scenes with real models, and it is aimed squarely at people selling merch rather than at general design. If the scene you need exists anywhere, it probably exists here.
Canva's case is that mockups cost nothing. They arrive inside a design suite most sellers already have open, the library grew considerably when Canva absorbed Smartmockups, and there is no separate subscription to justify.
What makes this comparison unusual is that the strongest argument against the paid option is not about the product. Placeit's Trustpilot score is 2, and its one-star reviews are overwhelmingly about cancellation and unexpected charges rather than about the mockups, which reviewers largely do not complain about. One two-star reviewer sums up the shape of it: the site was generally good for years, and ending the subscription took weeks. That belongs in this decision, because a subscription you cannot leave is a different product from one you can.
| What you are comparing | Winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Catalogue size | Placeit | The largest browser library here, and not close. If a specific lifestyle scene exists anywhere, it is most likely here. |
| Price | Canva Mockups | Mockups are on the free plan. A paid library has to beat free rather than beat Canva, which is a much higher bar. |
| Ease of cancelling | Canva Mockups | Placeit's one-star reviews are dominated by people describing charges after cancellation and support that did not respond. |
| Lifestyle scenes with models | Placeit | Deeper and more merch-specific. This is the gap people actually pay for, and it is a real one. |
| Breadth beyond mockups | Canva Mockups | Presentations, social, video and print in the same tool. Placeit does merch assets; Canva does the rest of your week. |
| Reusing a listing set | Tie | Neither has any concept of it. Both compose images one at a time, however large the catalogue behind them is. |
Page states billing is in USD regardless of viewing country. Headline price is the annual rate.
Paid tier pricing not captured yet.
Our own pricing.
Breadth is the product. If the exact setting matters and Canva does not have it, this is what you are paying for.
Free covers occasional use comfortably, and a subscription that idles is the most expensive kind.
Leaving is the step people underestimate, and it is where Placeit's reviews are worst by a wide margin.
Catalogue size does not touch repetition. A bigger library still means composing each listing image by hand.
Envato's mockup and template library, sold as one unlimited subscription with the largest ready made catalogue of any browser tool.
Page states billing is in USD regardless of viewing country. Headline price is the annual rate.
Sellers who want the widest possible library of ready made scenes and are happy to compose each listing image themselves.
Canva's mockup feature, and now the home of Smartmockups too, bolted onto a full design editor.
Paid tier pricing not captured yet.
Anyone already designing in Canva who lists rarely enough that rebuilding each image by hand has not started to hurt yet.
Generally a good experience using the site over the last few years, but so much difficulty cancelling now I want to end my monthly subscription. Tried to cancel for two weeks to no avail, even though I submitted a ticket for support about my issue over a week ago. So, to ensure that I'm not billed again next month, I accepted the 'free month' offer they share when you go through the cancellation process and then deactivated the automatic withdrawal on Paypal. Beware before signing up, because cancelling is not as easy as they make it seem.
After being duped into believing this was an easy way to create and upload POD merch, I now see after paying for a years subscription, it was a total waste of money! The content is elementary at best. There are virtually no editing tools and the entire platform is anything but user friendly. This is totally useless! Yes, I'm Pissed!!
Its not free! Why you write "free" when you have to pay to download mockup? 0 STARS!!!!
Unreliable! I pay for this platform and they have two fundamental problems: 1. they often change usability, things move, change, get deleted and 2. Outages!! Their servers cannot cope. I often have issues with uploading, continuous circle trying to upload and getting no-where. It could be a brilliant tool, but the unreliability makes it difficult.
Have you actually run out of scenes in Canva, or is bigger just appealing in the abstract?
How many mockups will you make next month? A subscription that idles is the most expensive kind.
Do you know how to cancel it, and have you put the renewal date somewhere you will see it?
Is the constraint the scene library or the repetition? Those need different tools, and only one is on this page.
Both of these answer the question of which scenes exist. Neither answers what to do when the same five listing images have to be rebuilt for every new design, which is where the hours actually go for anyone selling more than a handful of products. That is our job: describe the set once, drop in each new design, and get the finished images back with your title, size chart and logo already placed. It is a different bottleneck from the one a catalogue solves, and it sits alongside either of these rather than replacing them.
Only if the catalogue is genuinely your constraint. Placeit's library is substantially larger, particularly for merch lifestyle scenes. If you have not actually run out of scenes in Canva, you are paying for breadth you are not using.
Its Trustpilot score is 2, and the one-star reviews are mostly about billing rather than mockups: charges continuing after cancellation, and slow or absent support. Reviewers rarely complain about the images themselves.
Better than it used to be. Canva absorbed Smartmockups and inherited much of that catalogue, which is why smartmockups.com now redirects there. It is smaller than Placeit's but no longer thin.
That is the most common complaint against it, so plan for it. Several reviewers describe cancelling and continuing to be charged. One two-star reviewer, otherwise positive about the product, describes it taking weeks.
It saves you searching, not composing. However many scenes exist, each listing image is still assembled by hand, once per product. If the hours are going into repetition rather than into finding the right scene, Custom Mockup Generator is aimed at that instead.
Placeit is more merch-focused and its scenes are aimed at sellers. Canva is more general and free. Neither reruns a listing set, so if you sell many designs, that limitation applies to both equally.
Describe your listing set once, then drop in each new design and get the whole set back with your title, size chart and logo already in place.
Browse apparel generators